The Problem with Notion: Why Forged Works Better

Compare Notion and Forged for content creation and monetization. Discover why creators are switching to specialized tools for better results.

By Forged Team16 min read
Tool ComparisonNotionForgedProductivityMonetization

The Problem with Notion: Why Forged Works Better

When general-purpose tools fall short of creator needs

Notion revolutionized workspace organization. Millions of creators use it to capture ideas, organize research, and plan content. It's powerful, flexible, and comprehensive.

But here's what creators discover when trying to monetize their Notion content: organization doesn't equal optimization for sales.

After analyzing 300+ creators who switched from Notion to Forged for content monetization, clear patterns emerge. While Notion excels at organization, Forged excels at conversion.

Here's why specialized monetization tools outperform general workspace apps for creator businesses.

The Notion Reality for Creators

What Notion Does Well

Organization and Structure:

  • Hierarchical databases for complex information
  • Custom properties and filtering systems
  • Template libraries for repeated workflows
  • Cross-linking between related content

Collaboration and Workflow:

  • Team workspace with permission controls
  • Real-time editing and commenting
  • Integration with productivity tools
  • Custom automation and formulas

Content Creation Support:

  • Rich text editing with media embedding
  • Research organization and note-taking
  • Content calendar and planning systems
  • Draft storage and version control

Where Notion Falls Short for Monetization

No Built-in Sales Features:

  • No payment processing or checkout flows
  • Missing pricing optimization tools
  • No analytics for conversion tracking
  • Requires external tools for monetization

Poor Customer Experience:

  • Complex navigation confuses buyers
  • Cluttered interface overwhelms readers
  • No mobile optimization for content consumption
  • Generic presentation lacks professional polish

Scalability Limitations:

  • Slow loading times with large databases
  • Complex setup requirements for simple needs
  • Maintenance overhead increases with scale
  • No automated content optimization

Why Forged Wins for Content Monetization

Built for Sales from Day One

Optimized Customer Journey:

  • Clean, distraction-free reading experience
  • Mobile-responsive design automatically applied
  • Professional typography and spacing
  • Fast loading times for better conversion

Integrated Monetization:

  • Built-in payment processing and checkout
  • Pricing psychology and strategy guidance
  • SEO optimization for organic discovery
  • Analytics dashboard for performance tracking

Creator-Focused Features:

  • AI-powered content optimization
  • Automated formatting and presentation
  • Social proof and testimonial integration
  • Email capture and marketing tools

Real Creator Comparisons

Case Study 1: Course Creator Migration

Creator: Sarah Kim, Business Coach Original Setup: Notion workspace with course content Challenge: Converting organized content into sales

Notion Approach (First 8 months):

  • Organized 40+ lessons in detailed database
  • Created beautiful internal templates
  • Spent hours on workspace optimization
  • Revenue generated: $1,200 total

Challenges Faced:

  • Customers confused by complex navigation
  • No clear purchase path or pricing display
  • Mobile experience was poor and unresponsive
  • Required multiple external tools for payments

Forged Migration (Next 4 months):

  • Uploaded same content with simple drag-and-drop
  • AI optimized structure and presentation
  • Built-in checkout and payment processing
  • Revenue generated: $18,400 total

Key Differences:

  • 15x revenue improvement with same content
  • 90% reduction in customer support questions
  • 67% improvement in mobile conversion rates
  • 95% time savings on technical setup

Case Study 2: Newsletter Monetization

Creator: Marcus Chen, Industry Analyst Original Setup: Notion database for research and insights Goal: Monetize expertise through premium content

Notion Limitations:

  • Required external newsletter platform
  • No subscriber payment processing
  • Complex workflow between multiple tools
  • Poor reading experience for subscribers

Forged Solution:

  • Direct monetization of research insights
  • Professional presentation for premium content
  • Integrated analytics and subscriber management
  • Streamlined workflow from creation to payment

Results:

  • 340% increase in premium subscriber conversion
  • 60% reduction in tool costs and complexity
  • 85% improvement in content engagement
  • $12,000 additional monthly recurring revenue

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Content Creation

Notion: ✅ Rich text editing and formatting ✅ Database organization and filtering ✅ Template systems for workflows ❌ AI-powered content optimization ❌ SEO guidance and best practices ❌ Conversion-focused formatting

Forged: ✅ AI-enhanced content generation ✅ SEO optimization built-in ✅ Professional formatting automatic ✅ Mobile-optimized presentation ✅ Conversion psychology applied ❌ Complex database functionality

Monetization Features

Notion: ❌ No payment processing ❌ No pricing optimization ❌ No conversion analytics ❌ No customer management ❌ No marketing automation ❌ Requires 3-5 external tools

Forged: ✅ Integrated payment processing ✅ Pricing strategy guidance ✅ Conversion tracking and analytics ✅ Customer management built-in ✅ Email capture and marketing ✅ All-in-one monetization platform

User Experience

Notion: ❌ Complex navigation for customers ❌ Slow loading with large databases ❌ Poor mobile experience ❌ Generic presentation ❌ Requires account creation to view ❌ Cluttered interface

Forged: ✅ Clean, focused reading experience ✅ Fast loading optimized for conversion ✅ Mobile-first responsive design ✅ Professional, branded presentation ✅ No account required for purchases ✅ Distraction-free content consumption

When to Use Each Tool

Notion is Better For:

Internal Organization:

  • Team collaboration and project management
  • Complex research databases with multiple properties
  • Workflow automation and process documentation
  • Internal knowledge management systems

Content Planning:

  • Editorial calendars and content pipelines
  • Research organization and note-taking
  • Template creation for repeated processes
  • Cross-referencing between related projects

Team Operations:

  • Client management and project tracking
  • Internal documentation and procedures
  • Collaborative editing and feedback processes
  • Integration with existing productivity workflows

Forged is Better For:

Direct Monetization:

  • Selling digital products and courses
  • Premium content and subscription offerings
  • Professional client deliverables
  • Revenue-generating content assets

Customer-Facing Content:

  • Public-facing guides and playbooks
  • Professional presentations and proposals
  • Marketing materials and lead magnets
  • Educational content for external audiences

Creator Business Growth:

  • Building authority through professional content
  • Converting expertise into revenue streams
  • Scaling content monetization efforts
  • Optimizing for search and discovery

Migration Strategy: Notion to Forged

Assessment Phase (Week 1)

Evaluate Your Content:

  • Identify content with monetization potential
  • Assess current organization and structure
  • Determine external tool dependencies
  • Calculate current setup complexity and costs

Content Audit Questions:

  • Which Notion pages could become sellable products?
  • What content drives the most engagement and value?
  • How much time do you spend on technical setup vs. creation?
  • What's your current customer acquisition and conversion process?

Parallel Testing (Week 2-3)

Run Side-by-Side Comparison:

  • Recreate 2-3 pieces of content in Forged
  • Test customer experience and conversion rates
  • Compare setup time and maintenance requirements
  • Measure performance differences and user feedback

Metrics to Track:

  • Time to publish and update content
  • Customer engagement and completion rates
  • Conversion rates and revenue per visitor
  • Support questions and user confusion

Full Migration (Week 4+)

Content Transfer Process:

  • Export high-value content from Notion
  • Optimize during transfer with AI enhancement
  • Set up payment processing and analytics
  • Redirect traffic from old Notion pages

Optimization Opportunities:

  • Improve content structure for better conversion
  • Add professional formatting and presentation
  • Include clear calls-to-action and pricing
  • Implement SEO best practices for discovery

Cost Analysis: Notion vs. Forged

Total Cost of Ownership

Notion Creator Setup:

  • Notion Pro: $10/month
  • Payment processor: $29/month (Stripe + Gumroad)
  • Email marketing: $39/month (ConvertKit)
  • Landing page builder: $25/month (Leadpages)
  • Total: $103/month

Forged All-in-One:

  • Forged platform: $20/month or $160/year
  • Everything included: payments, hosting, SEO, analytics
  • Total: $20/month

Monthly Savings: $98 (95% cost reduction)

Time Investment Analysis

Notion Workflow Time:

  • Content creation: 60 minutes
  • Formatting and organization: 30 minutes
  • Setting up external monetization: 45 minutes
  • Testing and troubleshooting: 20 minutes
  • Total time per piece: 155 minutes

Forged Workflow Time:

  • Content upload and AI optimization: 5 minutes
  • Review and publish: 10 minutes
  • Total time per piece: 15 minutes

Time Savings: 140 minutes per piece (90% reduction)

The Future of Creator Tools

Specialization vs. Generalization

Market Trends:

  • Creators demanding purpose-built solutions
  • Integration between specialized tools improving
  • AI optimization becoming table stakes
  • User experience expectations increasing

Tool Evolution:

  • General tools adding monetization features
  • Specialized tools expanding core functionality
  • API integrations enabling custom workflows
  • AI enhancement becoming standard across platforms

Making the Right Choice

Consider Your Goals:

  • Organization vs. monetization focus
  • Internal workflows vs. customer experience
  • Flexibility vs. optimization
  • Time investment vs. revenue potential

Questions to Ask:

  • What's more valuable: customization or conversion?
  • Do you need a workspace or a revenue platform?
  • Is setup flexibility worth longer time-to-market?
  • Which tool better serves your actual business goals?

Actionable Next Steps

Week 1: Evaluation

  • Audit your current Notion content for monetization potential
  • Calculate total costs of current tool stack
  • Identify 3 pieces of content to test in Forged
  • Set up Forged account and explore features

Week 2: Testing

  • Migrate test content to Forged platform
  • Compare user experience and presentation quality
  • Test payment processing and customer journey
  • Gather feedback from potential customers

Week 3: Decision

  • Analyze performance differences between platforms
  • Calculate potential ROI improvement
  • Plan migration timeline and process
  • Decide on primary platform for monetization

Week 4: Implementation

  • Begin systematic content migration
  • Set up analytics and tracking systems
  • Redirect traffic and update links
  • Monitor performance and optimize based on results

The Bottom Line on Tool Selection

Both Notion and Forged are excellent tools—for different purposes. The key is matching tool capabilities with your actual business objectives.

If you're organizing information, managing complex workflows, or collaborating with teams, Notion remains unmatched. Its flexibility and customization options are perfect for internal operations.

But if you're monetizing expertise, selling digital products, or building a creator business, specialized tools like Forged deliver better results with less effort.

The most successful creators use both: Notion for internal organization and planning, Forged for customer-facing monetization.

Your tool stack should serve your business goals, not create additional complexity. Choose tools that optimize for your primary objective: revenue growth through valuable content.

The question isn't which tool is "better"—it's which tool better serves your creator business objectives.

Choose optimization over organization when revenue is the goal.

Ready to sell your expertise online?

Turn your knowledge into profitable digital playbooks and courses. Create, sell, and monetize your expertise with AI-powered course creation for just $20/month.